I’m sorry guys. I know this is mean. Flashing pictures of ridiculous cookies like these without much warning just isn’t fair. I actually had to go downstairs to the kitchen to get some food while I was putting this post together since my stomach was going haywire and started to sound like an angry animal. What can I say, cookies bring out the beast in me. BEAST MODE.
Sometimes I don’t even know where I’m going when I start typing up these posts. At one mine I’m like yeah! Grumbling stomach! I’ll talk about that! Then somehow I find a way to branch between being hungry to cookies my inner animal to come out. Like woah there, Christine. Where are you possibly trying to go with this. Can we just try to pretend my writing is coherent? Purrrttty please?
You guys daaaa best <3.
I’m going to go out and say it right now. These cookies aren’t healthy. They are loaded down with sugar and chocolate and oodles of gooey peanut butter and everything else that’s good in life. RAINBOWS. UNICORNS. ZAC EFRON. It’s packed with the things that are good for your soul. They’re what your dessert dreams are made of and are completely over-the-top with a super fudgy and thick brownie-esq cookie, a beautiful pat of fluffy peanut butter frosting, and a drizzle of extra chocolate because why the heck not. Might as well go overboard, right?
Overboard it is. I took half of these cookies over to Kyle’s family when we went back home for the weekend and they luurrrveeed them. His dad’s reaction was “these are stupid” *cue heart dropping sadness*… “stupid GOOD!” and his mom exclaimed “OMG, KYLE” as she took a bite into one. Not bad reactions if ya ask me!
Stupid “good” – Hahaha! What a funny guy. I just went ahead and shared this link with another pregnant friend of mine here in Kuwait. I told her we need to make them asap. I’m sure Jailyn & Jenna would love them..although they may be on a sugar high & start kicking my ribs harddddd! Ha
You seriously make the tastiest looking sweets everrrr
These look like the perfect cookie to take to a holiday party. ESPECIALLY if they contain rainbows and Zac Efron 😀
Zac Efron….hahahha you seriously make me Laugh Out Loud. Not in a “lol” way like a literal burst of laughter.
Thank you for that!! These cookies..well I must look away… if I make them I will not share them. 😉
I’ve been meaning to make buckeye brownies for a longgg time! This may be the push I need to try some out only in cookie form! These look so amazing!
Whyyyy, why, why?! These are beautiful!! Love that pan too! So cute. I really don’t bake very often because when I do I can’t stop eating. Maybe you should just send me a couple of these
Every single thing about these looks so darn delicious. Peanut butter and chocolate are my jam!
It’s times like this that I really do curse my peanut allergy because these look ah.maze.ing and I want them in my life. Actually, I just want cookies and chocolate in my life. Thank goodness that Christmas and cookie season is coming up 😀
Oh my goodness Christine you make my life. Beast mode! Inner animal! ZAC. EFRON, <3
These cookies look better than Zac Efron, though. And coming from me, that's saying a lot. 😉 I cannnnn't freaking way to make these. Now. Not on December 4th. Life is hard.
Ahh I just made a version of these for a friends birthday! I didn’t get to try one because of dietary reasons but I totally munched on the buckeyes in the middle! So so good!
These are some of the best cookies I’ve had in a loooong time! Really, really good! 😀
WOOOO! So glad you liked them! <3
These are my kind of cookies!!
You are killing it with the awesome brownie recipes lately! These brownie cookies look unreal
Pinned!!!
I am right there with Kyle’s parents. They look AMAZING!! Such a great combo of ingredients.
I’ll Not leave my house today Until i made these cookies….
Awesome recipe!
Just wanted to let you know that I made these last week (although – without the PB & Choc topping since I love “plain” cookies more) and they turned out great! I thought I made them quite big and that they were undercooked, so I left the last ones in the oven a little longer.
To anyone perhaps thinking the same thing – don’t do it… they’re still good, but they’re definitely much better when they look underdone when you remove them (don’t worry, they’ll be just PERFECT by the time they cool off).
Hooray! So glad they were tasty for ya! Though I have to admit, I can’t help but think you’re a little crazy for liking plain cookies more ;). Thanks for the advice for other readers!